Val McDermid – The Skeleton Road


, , , , ,

Complex history and investigations, successfully explained; not completely successfully a novel.

Skeleton RoadI had mixed reactions to Val McDermid’s cleverly titled novel, a murder investigation which leads to exploring the deep issues within global conflict, and how love, in its widest reaches, and revenge, are not by any means in opposition to each other, but bedfellows.

Karen Pirie, a remarkably and satisfyingly well-functioning DCI, (not a dysfunctional ‘maverick’!) who heads up the ‘Cold Cases’ Unit is investigating a dead body found in a rather surprising location. The case leads her to a meeting with Maggie Blake, an Oxford professor of geopolitics. Blake was involved in underground liberal/radical feminist education programmes, and war relief programmes in Croatia, during the Serbo-Croat and wider war taking place after the break-up of Yugoslavia.

Pirie and Blake are both strong, extremely likeable, plausible intelligent complex women, well-functioning, both have strong friendships, and either have, or had, good supportive relationships with their respective other halves. Neither are dysfunctional.

Meanwhile, during the wind-up of the war crimes investigations unit, a couple of lawyers are involved in another enquiry, as their brisk and dynamic new broom of a boss tries to uncover the reason why so many war criminals, with lengthy cases prepared against them, appear to meet underground rough justice and be offed before the slow legal wheels bring them to trial

The narrative effectively unfolds in 4 voices, and the book constantly cuts between them Blake has a third person voice in the present, though her history throughout the 90s is a first person narrative. It took me a little time to work out what was going on here, and why. Pirie’s voice (third person narrative) is the other major strand

The two ‘buffoons’ from ICTFY, International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, Macanespie and Proctor, are almost like a world weary, seedier version of those beloved characters originally appearing in Hitchcock’s The Lady Vanishes, Charters and Caldicott, who then recycled into other films and even a TV series of their own. They add humour in their bumbling, often rather inept investigation and love/hate rivalry. Without these two, the story would be unremitting in its bleakness.

Former Yugoslavia 2008, Wiki Commons

Former Yugoslavia 2008, Wiki Commons

So – in effect, there are 3 investigations, plus a fourth, run by Pirie’s partner, also a cop, heading up a different division investigating domestic violence crimes.

My ‘with reservation’ reactions to The Skeleton Road, which did not really abate till around half way through the book, were caused by the problems of marrying excellent research and explanation into the novel form. In order to give the reader the information needed to understand the background, McDermid uses the device of having characters deliver lectures to each other, even when both of them know the same facts, and have drawn similar conclusions. This tricky, clumsy device is for our edification, and is not part of ‘narrative and character in relationship’

I was absolutely drawn into ‘being clearly taught complex information and the history of the conflict within former Yugoslavia’, (McDermid’s journalistic background and ability to explain complexity clearly much in evidence) but aware that there were sections which were breaking the back of the needs of a novel . The narrative and the psychology of character were ring-fenced and to a certain extent on hold as these were forced to carry the burden of reader instruction.

In the Balkans, the shortest distance between two points is never a straight line. History and geography have constantly collided with the human capacity for cruelty in those disputed territories

And then, finally, came a tipping point. Pirie and Blake eventually connect and pool their knowledge, skills and professional abilities, as for different reasons they are drawn to uncover something in the very dark history of that ‘former Yugoslavia’ and the conflict after (and before) Yugoslavia came into being. From that point, the novel as a novel, where the ‘about’, the narrative, and the psychology of believable character and action work beautifully together, held me fast.

I do, strongly, recommend this, even if the earlier parts of the novel, though excellent,
are not quite ‘excellently a novel’

Smiles all round … Val McDermid at the official naming of the new mortuary. Photograph: Dave Martin/Fotopress Dundee (published in The Guardian and appears as 'for reuse' on advanced search)

Smiles all round … Val McDermid at the official naming of the new mortuary. Photograph: Dave Martin/Fotopress Dundee (published in The Guardian and appears as ‘for reuse’ on advanced search)

I received this as a copy for review purposes, from the publisher, Little, Brown via NetGalley. My digital review copy had quite a lot of awkward typographical errors, which I assume will have been eradicated in the paid for download

I’m grateful to fellow blogger FictionFan whose review of this led to my scurry-to-read

The Skeleton Road Amazon UK
The Skeleton Road Amazon USA

Damon Galgut – Arctic Summer


, , ,

E.M. Forster and the writing of A Passage To India

Arctic SummerI have struggled, to some extent, with Damon Galgut’s ‘biographical novel’ about E.M. Forster, Arctic Summer, which uses the title of an ‘incomplete’ novel Forster wrote, which was unpublished in his lifetime.

The subject matter of the book is two-fold, taking as it does not a cradle-to-grave biographical approach, but an examination of the process of writing itself, particularly the writing of A Passage To India, and also, Forster’s struggle with the straitjackets of his class, at a particular time in history and in geography (the time of Empire) and of a sexuality which was not only illegal, but, for a large part of his life, shameful to Forster, whether expressed or not.

My struggle with this book, much as I admire Galgut’s writing, is that he is himself a writer with a tendency to conceal as much as he reveals. He is a writer of spare and beautiful prose, but the reader is deliberately not drawn in. There is a reserve in his writing. This does of course perfectly fit his subject in this book. Forster was also a man of reserve, both through the entirely stiff upper lip repressed attitudes of the times, rendered even more obvious in Forster because he did have so much to hide, and in many ways was so very unlike the hearty, anti-intellectual Empire builders of the time, who did not mingle socially with, and indeed despised, ‘the natives’.

This was a vigorous, outdoor world, full of sports and guns. If you didn’t join the club or play polo or shoot tigers or subdue barbarous tribes on the borders, you were immediately an unsound quantity, the more so if,…you lived in your mind a great deal and wrote books. Of what earthly use were novels? How did they help anybody?

So, Galgut, a writer of some reserve, and a tendency to a kind of cool unfervent mysticism – most potently seen in In A Strange Room – writes about Forster, who seems similarly reserved. Both men are/were clearly both deeply thinking and deeply feeling, but the ‘Only Connect’ central to, I believe, both writers, is not easy, in either of them. Reserved writing about a Reserved writer in the end left me wanting more, as the book wore on.

Now in an extended clarity, he saw the way forward. He had wanted the story to open out, and suddenly it had, in the most Indian of ways, into wider questions about the universe

It’s strengths for me were in the earlier part of the book, where the absolute awfulness of living at a time and in a place where sexual orientation was so rigidly and restrictedly defined and culturally and legally controlled, are beautifully expressed. Galgut does not use polemic, or bang drums, or preach to a possibly largely converted audience, but, almost dispassionately, lays out what is/was, and lets the effect of that resonate for the reader. His recounting of the sense of shame and self loathing which so many ‘minories’ inhabited, was deeply distressing.

E.M.Forster painted by Dora Carrington,  Wiki Commons

E.M.Forster painted by Dora Carrington, Wiki Commons

Forster’s discomfort with the prevailing racist, classist attitudes of his peers, AND his sense of shame and self-loathing at the times he became aware of those self-same attitudes within him, also formed a telling part of the story.

It is perhaps inevitable that ‘Forster the man’ and the difficulties and challenges which Galgutarise through being part of one culture, time and place, are more immediately resonant to a reader who is not a novelist than the interesting (but, for me, more cerebrally experienced) passages about writing itself, and particularly the gestation and difficulties of writing A Passage To India, which at times for me became a little dry. I very much admire Forster’s writing, but was less interested, in this case, in the process of that writing, whereas the man within the larger world, within his time, was absolutely absorbing

He had cut himself open and showed the innermost part; it had been rash and unconsidered and regrettable. Now he had to close himself up again, to seal the carapace, and he began to do what was necessary. It was part of a willed cheerfulness he had learned back in his childhood already, as protection against disappointment. The only defence against raw, naked feeling was reason. Understanding made sadness easier to bear

Arctic Summer Amazon UK
Arctic Summer Amazon USA

Emily St. John Mandel – Station Eleven


, , , ,

A perfect apocalypseStation Eleven proof.indd

Station Eleven is a wonderful book

Arthur Leander, theatre and film star, a much marrying actor, suffers a heart attack whilst performing in an avant-garde production of King Lear in Toronto

A member of the audience, a paramedic in training, attempts unsuccessfully to keep him from dying.

A small girl, part of that avant-garde production, looks on.

Later that evening, the unstoppable, virulent pandemic waiting to happen, which may end it for us all, in these days of endless global travel, makes its presence felt, and everything is forever changed

By twenty years after the event, life in a depopulated world is reduced to small collections of people on the margins.

The major focus of the novel concerns a small group of artists, the Travelling Symphony – actors and musicians, travelling in horse drawn vehicles, performing classical music and Shakespeare, because “Survival is Insufficient”

King Lear and A Midsummer Night’s Dream figure, but so too, almost as an undercurrent, does The Tempest – a sense of, at the end ‘O brave new world that has such people in’t’. Not to mention the creator of Station Eleven itself.

There is also a mysterious prophet, running a millennial cult, ruling by peddling lies of special redemption for the chosen men, and taking young girls as his ‘brides’, in the way that such cults, and their leaders, have often done

There is a beautifully drawn handcrafted comic ‘Station Eleven’ whose limited volumes feature a station in the vastness of space, the world having suffered an apocalypse. Dr Eleven looks majestically into the end times.

Comic panels and Book Cover artwork by Nathan Burton,

Comic panels and Book Cover artwork by Nathan Burton,

Out of this is woven the most beautiful narrative, full of hope as well as grief and despair.

This is not (just) the normal gritty realism of how-we-will-return-to-savagery-and-the-rule-of-brute-force when the end days come, and the world as we know it is out of the things we take for granted which make it run. It’s a more delicate, subtle, thing, and chooses also to focus upon that kindness and compassion which is as much a part of our nature as the self-will.

It’s a great and compulsive page turner, and the way in which Canadian author Emily St. John Mandel weaves together lives, artefacts, connected and pivotal moments is dizzyingly apt, and without any feeling of contrivance

And to my utter delight, there were no chain saw massacres, no gratuitous excuses for impossible x rated violence, no zombies, no werewolves, no vampires. Nothing that happens stretches plausibility at all. The magic of the book is the magic of ordinary. Ordinary people, ordinary extraordinary lives and events

I received this as an digital review copy via NetGalley. There were some EmilyStJohnMandel1SMALLformatting blips, and I assume these are limited to the review, rather than the finally available digital download

And thank you to WanderRaven whose review of this one initially made me scurry for it as fast as I could go to say my pretty pleases to NetGalley

Station Eleven Amazon UK
Station Eleven Amazon USA


Andrea Levy – Six Stories and an essay – It’s publication day!


, ,

Six stories and an essay


It’s publication day for Andrea Levy’s sharp short stories about the experience of being British, black, with a Caribbean ancestry. Within the collection of stories she gives each one a setting relating to when she wrote it, and what inspired it. The stories are preceded by a thoughtful, interesting essay on her own relationship with recognising the twined strands of being British, black, Caribbean ancestry, and putting that into a wider context

Here is my original review, written after receiving it as an ARC from the publishers

Six Stories and an essay Amazon UK
Six Stories and an essay Amazon USA

Sarah Moss – Names for the Sea: Strangers In Iceland


, , ,

Elves, SUVs, underfloor heating, a love of learning and the cult of the new.

Names-for-the-Sea-imageThough definitely a person who basks in hotter-the-better sun, I am lured and also terrified by the climates of harsh, cold, isolation.

So Sarah Moss’s obsession with, love of Iceland, biographical account of a year spent living and working there, was always going to be an absorbing read. In many ways my interest is as much in ‘how does a person coming from one culture assimilate into another’ as it is in learning about a different culture; that is because the outsider sees things the in-dweller cannot, because it is so much part of their fabric that they can’t step outside it.

Moss first went to Iceland when she was 19, over a university summer holiday, with a friend. By the time covered by this book, she is in her thirties, married, with two children, and a university lecturer (and of course a writer) This is post-the collapse of Iceland, and she had a accepted a lecturing commitment for a year at Reykjavik University. By the time she got there, her salary had so far dropped in its buying power as to make living there for the year quite hard.

Reykjavik Wiki Commons

Reykjavik Wiki Commons

What she found puzzling is that certainly amongst the middle classes she could not really see much evidence of what ‘collapse’ had done to society, as, in boom, Iceland had moved to be a highly consumerist culture, households with several gas guzzling vehicles, a society of perennial new spend and dumping (not recycling, not sell-or-give-away-as second-hand) of the mildly out-moded but still fully functioning. She discovered this, even, in small children’s clothing. Unlike her middle-class-British-society, where mums were cheerfully passing on clothes to other mums 3 months behind them in child-age, to the Icelanders, there was something distasteful and a little shameful in this:

The Icelandic horror at the idea of the second-hand seems to be partly to do with the impossibility of anonymity here, the fear of ‘strangers’ The risk is one of disclosure, that the person who classified the object as ‘trash’ might see the same object reclassified by someone else…..this is why secondhand clothes are so terrible, because the anonymity of charitable giving might be broken, you might recognise your child’s outgrown clothes on someone else and thus have to acknowledge some kind of hierarchy. One of the most widely held beliefs among Icelanders is that there is no hierarchy here

Lopi sweaterMoss is both a lover of Iceland, and its people, and bemused and at times critical of it. During her year she also discovered that some of what Iceland told about itself TO itself – such as its low crime figures were just not true, and, even discovered in the forays she made with Icelandic friends around the country as her year drew to its close, that they too were starting to see a hidden Iceland that they had not known existed.


Along the way we meet the modern tradition of ‘Icelandic knitting’ (not something dating back to Viking times at all), a belief in elves alive and well, and of course, the ‘old’ diet, divorced of fresh fruit and vegetables, for large parts of the year, later superseded, as Iceland entered its boom years by exotic greengrocery from all over the world, now returning, as the price of food sky-rocketed, to earlier privations

And, of course, there is much that hinges up an inescapably close relationship Sarah-Mosswith climate, geography, landscape and the rules imposed by a far more dramatic relationship with day and night, cold and colder, than we have in most of these isles.

Names For The Sea : Strangers In Iceland Amazon UK
Names For The Sea : Strangers In Iceland Amazon UK

Izy Hossack – Top With Cinnamon


, , , ,

Enchanted by Izy (beloved by dentists!)

top-with-cinnamonI have been bowled over by Izy almost against my will. YES this book is not going to be one of the cookbooks in daily use, mainly because it is really a sweet and sticky bakes and desserts book, with a few main dishes and savoury (and LOTS of sweet) snacks thrown in for good measure.

BUT Izy is 18, bubbling over with enthusiasm, loves cooking, loves eating, and just expresses such joie de vivre and desire to SHARE the pleasure that it would take a harder-hearted, surlier cynic than I would ever want to be, NOT to roll over, surrender and say, ah, bless, good on you, and……mm let me into the kitchen and attabake NOW

This would particularly be a fabulous book for other young chefs or would be chefs. She is refreshingly ‘hey, this is FUN!, this is COOL! This is EASY!’ and though at times I squinted at the text (tiny, tiny) and thought there might be an overkill of photos and not QUITE enough recipes, I felt a churl for even thinking this.

As a vegetarian some of the (Not that many) main dishes are of course NOT FOR ME, so we will draw a veil over them, and those that want to see can look at the index on a ‘look inside’

This is a very helpful book for the utter novice cook, as Izy shows and tells how to make such staples as bread dough, pastry, not to mention how to prepare and line cake tins and roll-out and prepare pastry in a flan tin, and how to make various staples she uses a lot of such as chocolate and hazelnut butter and chocolate ganache.

But how can a fellow chocolate lover NOT surrender to Izy, a serious chocca young lady if ever there was one – Chocolate Chip Amaretto Torte, Swedish chocolate cake, boozy mocha Coconut Layer Cake (sandwiched with that chocolate ganache yum) and the like.

You can keep your surly bad tempered chefs who dishearten the rest of us with complexity. Izy Hossack is infectiously joyous, as are her recipes It must be a surfeit of endorphins from all that chocolate.

AND should you decide you would like more Izy recipes, there is her blog, surprisingly entitled Top With Cinnamon.

A picture for Coconut Bostock - recipe on her site Top With Cinnamon

A picture for Coconut Bostock – recipe on her site Top With Cinnamon

Very helpfully, Izy who lives in the UK has an American Italian mother, so she covers every single base on the measurement, – the weighted ones, Imperial and Metric, and those frankly WEIRD (to a Brit) Stateside volume ones, for her baking recipes, so meaning her book can be happily used by all!

Izy’s other enthusiasm is photography, so the visuals, as well as the food (and no doubt the choice of that tiny text!) is also testament to her creative skills

Second edition, maybe she’ll turn the font size up! (Okay, that’s the advantage if you get this in eread, but then..losing those lovely photos!)

I happily received this from the Amazon Vine UK programme as a review copy

Top With Cinnamon Amazon UK
Top With Cinnamon Amazon USA

Andrea Levy – Six Stories & an essay


, ,

Left wanting more – seven, eight, nine or ten!

Six stories and an essayI was delighted to get this as an ARC from the publisher. Having appreciated Small Island, I was curious to see how Levy handled the short story genre. Reading a selection of short stories by a writer can at times be a challenging experience, because if the reader is quite a fast reader, each story may be completed too quickly, and to read several all at once is a bit like devouring a box of chocolates in one sitting – you can end up feeling a bit overindulged, and wish you’d taken longer to truly savour each gem! Also, as far as stories, rather than chocolates go, a whole bunch of short stories leaves the reader sometimes in the position of having sussed the authorial tricks, as the trajectory of shape and structure of a short story is easier to see fairly quickly.

All the stories are of high calibre, and each one is introduced by a photograph, and an introduction where she sets each within its time and place of gestation.

The Empire Windrush photo Hulton Getty

The Empire Windrush photo Hulton Getty

However, I found it was the ‘and an essay’ which most sustained my interest, where Levy charts her personal experience of being a black Briton, and her growing awareness of herself as a writer, a black writer, a Briton, and her Caribbean roots. She beautifully brings all this together, closely knitting together the fact that there is an often unexplored mutual making of identity between Britain and The Caribbean, that both made each other what they are:

But there are still countless young Britons today of Afro-Caribbean descent who have as little understanding of their ancestry and have as little evidence of their worth as I did when I was growing up. And there are countless white Britons who are unaware of the histories that bind us together. Britain made the Caribbean that my parents came from. It provided the people – black and white – who made up my ancestry. In return my ancestors, through their forced labour and their enterprise, contributed greatly to the development of modern Britain. My heritage is Britain’s story too. It is time to put the Caribbean back where it belongs – in the main narrative of British history.

My particular favourite stories of the 6 are ‘Deborah’ the exploration of how childhood andrea-levy-001‘evil’ may begin, which was possibly a story which began to brew in the wake of James Bulger’s murder at the hands of two minors, and ‘That Polite Way That English People Have’, a story almost spinning off from A Small Island, which she was then writing, and based on her mother’s arrival in this country, from Jamaica, in 1948. It looks at class, race and how to survive and get on, and is both pointed, deftly painted and funny, making little needle like stabs through the light touch humour

Publication day is the 23rd October
Six Stories and an essay Amazon UK
Six Stories and an essay Amazon USA

Susan Hill – The Woman In Black


, , ,

As the nights get longer: ghosties and ghoulies and things that go bump in the night

the-woman-in-blackSusan Hill’s transmogrified-into-many-media “The Woman In Black” remains a wonderful, atmospheric ghost story, still holding its own after its 30 plus years in print. Though I’m – amazed/amused/shocked to find that it is now listed as a best seller on Amazon in the CHILDREN’S ebook category. I don’t believe it was initially written, or published, for that market. So I’m not quite sure what this shows – the literary sophistication of children? Sure, post a-film-starring-Daniel-Harry-Potter-Radcliffe, probably new audiences are coming to the book, but it is quite a slowly paced, literary piece of writing (hence its standing the test of time on a re-read for this reader). It’s a properly paced, slow-burn, atmospheric piece of writing, with a wonderful sense of lonely place – set on the North-East coast, much of the horror arises from Hill’s ability to create an eerie, beautiful, mysterious and isolated tidal estuary landscape, complete with the suckings and soughings, the glimmers, glistens and dankness of wind, water and sea-frets.

Arthur Kipps, now a middle aged man on his second marriage, is immured in a family Christmas. His teenage stepsons embark, in high spirits, on the telling of ghost stories

Unwillingly, the years roll back memories of a quarter of a century and more ago, when Kipps, as a young solicitor, was sent to deal with the estate of a recently deceased reclusive woman in her eighties, who had lived in isolation in a house at Eel Marsh, some distance from a little market town called Crythin Gifford. Eel Marsh can only be reached when the tide is out, and is then completely cut off from the outside world, and the outside world from it, once the tide comes in again. There was some unexplained horror to do with Eel Marsh. Locals drop veiled hints, but Kipps, a pragmatic, modern young man, not given to flights of fancy is of course dismissive…………..until.

This is a proper Victorian Gothic style story, even though set in a modern era. Everything is done through its effect on Kipps, the slow drip drip of fear and horror into his psyche. It’s a superb ratcheting up of horror, and there is nothing to cynically laugh at, no crass clankings of chains and slamming doors, opening graves and the like. Hill takes normality and just progressively makes it go wrong, chill and definitely evil.

We had travelled perhaps three miles, and passed no farm or cottage, no kind of dwelling house at all, all was emptiness. Then, the hedgerows petered out, and we seemed to be driving towards the very edge of the world. Ahead, the water gleamed like metal…..I realized this must be the Nine Lives Causeway…..and saw, how, when the tide came in, it would quickly be quite submerged and untraceable……..we went on, almost in silence, save for a hissing, silky sort of sound. Here and there were clumps of reeds, bleached bone-pale, and now and again the faintest of winds caused them to rattle dryly

And that’s BEFORE the sea-frets come!susanhill-007

A short, chilly, chilly, read. Hill is a writer who understands less is more and has no need for crude schlock effects.

The Woman In Black Amazon UK
The Woman In Black Amazon USA

Hilary Mantel – The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher


, ,

Deliciously spiteful!

The Assassination of Margaret ThatcherI never thought I would want to connect the two words put together in my title, but this is what this well crafted collection of short stories offers.

Mantel perfectly understands the trajectory of the short story, and each one is excellently crafted. In fact, the collection as a whole is contained by the first story, Sorry To Disturb, hooking to the last, title story.

Sorry to Disturb is set in Saudia Arabia in 1983, the story of a British woman (a reflection of Mantel herself) having to come to terms with life in that society, where she and her husband are now living. It has some similarities to Mantel’s novel with a similar setting, Eight Months on Ghazzah Street. In this edgy, claustrophobic story, where all `outsiders’ struggle to exist within new norms, reference is made to the 1983 election which returned Thatcher to power:

“Thursday June 9th………..When we turned out the light, the grocer’s daughter jigged through my dreams to the strains of `Lillibulero’. Friday was a holiday, and we slept undisturbed till the noon prayer call. Ramadan began. Wednesday June 15th: Read The Twyborn Affair and vomited sporadically’.”

The end plate story posits the assassination, and the timing of this story, I noted, coincides with the narrator of the first story and her husband being back in the UK on leave.

Almost every story is dark, nastily funny, and with a lethal sting in its tail. And perhaps unusually, as I could not resist reading this straight through, I didn’t second guess the wraps, which managed to be both surprising and satisfying.

What does unite almost all of them however is a sense of spite and delight in the spite (and is responsible for the fact that though I liked the collection, very very much, I didn’t quite love it)

The ones which worked most effectively for me, however, had more of a sense of unease, danger and unpredictability about them, relative to the central characters. This was particularly the case in stories where the central characters were not properly in control, and were even `outsiders’ in different ways. – hence the despair and difficulty of that first story, Sorry to Disturb. This story, one of my favourites, links also to the fourth story, Winter Break, where a childless couple travel out of season to a rocky, mountainous un-named (probably North African or possibly Spanish) location. The link between the two stories is childlessness, and biological clocks. Winter Break , like Sorry To Disturb, is less filled with spite as a driver, and does have a shape and a journey which is compellingly managed,

I also very much liked `Comma’ where adults and children are outsiders to each other, and explores in that territory where the unrestrained, uncivil, could be feral nature of childhood, and the cultural restraints children are learning, meet. The central child in this story, again, a kind of `proto Mantel’

`guarded, eight years old, wearing too-small shorts of black-and-white-check that had fitted me last year;’

has a cross-class friendship with another child of more weird and vibrant vitality.

`Harley Street’ I found wonderfully funny, and it rather cocks a snook at a certain popular genre which is often a dreary repository for sloppy writing. Mantel manages her foray into the area with great style, despite making some very bad and obvious jokes. Or, indeed, because of making those bad and obvious jokes

Every story seems to start, and end, with a satisfying hook and a bangMantel-sandison

Wholesome, it isn’t!

And I’m grateful to FictionFan for alerting me to this on her ‘currently reading’ queue, which sent me racing post haste to buy it. I’m afraid that though my newest download it leapfrogged everything else, courtesy of a weekend journey and the dreaded engineering works and Network Rail!

The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher Amazon UK
The Assassination of Margaret Thatcher Amazon USA

Emmanuel Carrère – Limonov


, , , ,

A most disturbing read

Limonov jacketTo be honest, I spent much of my time reading this biography with interpolations and explanations by the author, wondering what on earth I was doing, as Eduard Limonov, writer, manipulator and sometime leader of the banned National Bolshevik party, most often comes across as a brutal, narcissistic thug, a proto-fascist, and a man devoid of pity, fellow-feeling or compassion. At times, reading accounts of Limonov’s chosen early life, as a petty hoodlum in Ukraine, and later as a bum and shocking, Genet-ish, Henry Miller-ish writer of degradation in New York and Paris, with his overweening desire to be ‘someone’ whatever the cost, either to himself or anyone else, felt a little like rooting around salaciously in degradation, overwhelmed by half horrified, half fascinated prurience.

Limonov, born Savenko, adopted the name, as a play upon the sourness and clarity of the lemon, but it is also a Russian word for ‘grenade’, so indicated his propensity for violence, and to shatter complacency and the status quo.


French writer and film-maker Emmanuel Carrère, himself of part Russian descent, (his maternal grandfather was a White Russian émigré) is/was clearly both fascinated and repelled by Limonov. His rationale for writing this hybrid of biography AND autobiography is his belief that here is a man, in Limonov, through whom one can understand not just one man, but the whole history of Russia from the Second World War to the present day, and that the complexities, the darkness, degradation and brutality and yes, the light, and the mysticism within Limonov are in some way indicative of this complex country. And indeed, he suggests further that the confusion and complexity of Limonov’s nature and history also shows something about ‘’all our history since the end of World War II’’

What kept me reading was an appeal, by Carrère, to the reader, part way through the book, laying out a tenet from a Buddhist sutra :

A man who judges himself superior, inferior, or even equal to another does not understand reality.

and Carrère goes on to say

this idea….is the pinnacle of wisdom, and that one life isn’t enough to adopt it, digest it, and absorb it so that it ceases to be an idea and instead conditions at every moment our way of looking and acting. For me, writing this book is a strange way of attempting to do just that

This is an often horrible, depressing, distressing read, and yet, at times there is a kind Emmanuel_Carrère_2of dignity and honour in Limonov which Carrère makes the reader see…particularly in the account of his time in prison, as an avowed critic of Putin, where he seemed to win the respect of fellow prisoners and guards.

This is not in any way an easy or a comfortable read; yet I can’t do other than recommend it.

I received this as a review copy from Amazon Vine UK

Limonov Amazon UK
Limonov Amazon USA


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 325 other followers