• About
  • Listening
    • Baroque
    • Bluegrass and Country
    • Classical Fusion
    • Classical Period
    • Early Music
    • Film soundtracks
    • Folk Music
    • Jazz
    • Modern Classical
    • Modern Pop Fusion
    • Musicals
    • Romantic Classical
    • Spoken word
    • World Music
  • Reading
    • Fiction
      • Children’s and Young Adult Fiction
      • Classic writers and their works
      • Contemporary Fiction
      • Crime and Detective Fiction
      • Fictionalised Biography
      • Historical Fiction
      • Horror
      • Lighter-hearted reads
      • Literary Fiction
      • Plays and Poetry
      • Romance
      • SF
      • Short stories
      • Western
      • Whimsy and Fantastical
    • Non-Fiction
      • Arts
      • Biography and Autobiography
      • Ethics, reflection, a meditative space
      • Food and Drink
      • Geography and Travel
      • Health and wellbeing
      • History and Social History
      • Philosophy of Mind
      • Science and nature
      • Society; Politics; Economics
  • Reading the 20th Century
  • Watching
    • Documentary
    • Film
    • Staged Production
    • TV
  • Shouting From The Soapbox
    • Arts Soapbox
    • Chitchat
    • Philosophical Soapbox
    • Science and Health Soapbox
  • Interviews / Q + A
  • Indexes
    • Index of Bookieness – Fiction
    • Index of Bookieness – Non-Fiction
    • Index of authors
    • Index of titles
    • 20th Century Index
    • Sound Index
      • Composers Index
      • Performers Index
    • Filmed Index

Lady Fancifull

~ adventures in a mainly literary obsession

Lady Fancifull

Daily Archives: May 13, 2013

John Gray – The Silence of Animals

13 Monday May 2013

Posted by Lady Fancifull in Ethics, reflection, a meditative space, Non-Fiction, Philosophy of Mind, Reading

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Book Review, John Gray, Philosophy, The Silence of Animals

Gray areas

John GrayThis has been a difficult review to come to, as much of Gray’s book puzzled me. Not least, what exactly was he saying?

He is a brilliant stylistic writer – but sometimes, too much so, as his weary, epigrammatic style occasionally sacrifices clarity for a soundbite which is satisfying, but doesn’t pick apart so well

Echoing the Christian faith in free will, humanists hold that human beings are – or may sometimes become – free to choose their lives. They forget that the self that does the choosing has not itself been chosen

That last sentence has a beautiful structure to it which is typically Gray – but what exactly does it mean? I spent an age deciphering.

There are plenty of other places in this book where I found myself delighted by pithy, witty summings up:

Like cheap music, the myth of progress lifts the spirits as it numbs the brain

“When we discover something new about ourselves, we alter the person we have come to be”

The Silence of AnimalsHowever – and here is my problem, what exactly is the prophet of world weary doom actually saying:

1)    The idea of human shaped progress is a myth. Faiths and their followers, humanists and science all are deluded because they live by this myth.

2)    Anyone who says we can live without myths is foolish, and so the mythiest of myth makers (religions) understood our need to make sense of things through myth. Atheist scientists such as Dawkins may believe they are myth free but still subscribe to a myth – human shaped progress

3)    Mankind is an animal, though curiously unwilling to try and see the world from outside a human perspective which would let him experience that other realities exist

4)    There is no purpose, and the idea of spiritual progress, or the progress and evolution of humanity through science, or through philosophy is all foolish.

5)    Learn to accept a pragmatic despair and be present in the world here and now

With the inclusion, admiringly, of writers who had spent time attempting to ‘become one with an animal viewpoint’ I did begin to wonder whether this was all, at root, coming from understandable discomfort with what it means to be Homo sapiens. I concur completely that our tendency to only see the world through our own perspective as the be all and end all is misplaced, and leads to barbarism, but is J.A. Baker’s (one of the many writers Gray quotes) attempt to experience the world through the experience of peregrine falcon, any BETTER – it might be, for the peregrine – what of the lark?

Peregrine Falcon Wiki Commons

Peregrine Falcon Wiki Commons

Unlike an earlier book of Gray’s, The Immortalisation Commission where he was clearly examining 3 very different approaches to the horrifying knowledge of our own – and everyone we love’s, mortality, this book is much more confused and confusing. It is a bit of a scamper through patchwork of literary and philosophical writings, and for this reader, I kept losing the way, forgetting where we were going and what exactly Gray was attempting to clarify for me.

In the end, my fairly permanent question became “And Your Point Is?”

Flicr Commons

Flicr Commons

A Patchwork Quilt. At times, a very beautiful patchwork quilt, but it had a very odd shape and I’m not quite certain what to do with it!

I received this as an ARC through The Amazon Vine programme, UK
The Silence of Animals Amazon UK
The Silence of Animals Amazon USA

Advertisement

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Print
  • Email
  • More
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit
  • Pocket
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr

Like this:

Like Loading...

Page Indexes

  • About
    • Index of Bookieness – Fiction
    • Index of Bookieness – Non-Fiction
    • Index of authors
    • Index of titles
    • 20th Century Index
  • Sound Index
    • Composers Index
    • Performers Index
  • Filmed Index

Genres

Archives

May 2013
M T W T F S S
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  
« Apr   Jun »

Posts Getting Perused

  • Philip Glass - Glassworks
    Philip Glass - Glassworks
  • John Steinbeck - The Grapes of Wrath
    John Steinbeck - The Grapes of Wrath
  • Barbara Vine - House of Stairs
    Barbara Vine - House of Stairs
  • Cormac McCarthy - The Road
    Cormac McCarthy - The Road
  • Joanna Rakoff - My Salinger Year
    Joanna Rakoff - My Salinger Year
  • Christiane Ritter - A Woman In The Polar Night
    Christiane Ritter - A Woman In The Polar Night
  • Janine Jansen - Bach: Inventions & Partita
    Janine Jansen - Bach: Inventions & Partita
  • Virginia Woolf - The Voyage Out
    Virginia Woolf - The Voyage Out

Recent Posts

  • Bart Van Es – The Cut Out Girl
  • Joan Baez – Vol 1
  • J.S.Bach – Goldberg Variations – Zhu Xiao-Mei
  • Zhu Xiao-Mei – The Secret Piano
  • Jane Harper – The Lost Man

NetGalley Badges

Fancifull Stats

  • 162,942 hits
Follow Lady Fancifull on WordPress.com

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Follow on Bloglovin

Tags

1930s setting Adult Faerie Tale Andrew Greig Arvo Pärt Autobiography baroque Beryl Bainbridge Biography Biography as Fiction Bits and Bobs Bits and Pieces Book Review Books about Books Cats Children's Book Review Classical music Classical music review Classic Crime Fiction Colm Toibin Cookery Book Crime Fiction David Mitchell Dystopia Espionage Ethics Fantasy Fiction Feminism Film review First World War Folk Music Food Industry France Gay and Lesbian Literature Ghost story Golden-Age Crime Fiction Graham Greene Health and wellbeing Historical Fiction History Humour Humour and Wit Ireland Irish writer Irvin D. Yalom Janice Galloway Japan Literary Fiction Literary pastiche Lynn Shepherd Marcus Sedgwick Meditation Mick Herron Minimalism Music review Myths and Legends Neil Gaiman Ngaio Marsh Novels about America Other Stuff Patrick Flanery Patrick Hamilton Perfumery Philip Glass Philosophy Police Procedural Post-Apocalypse Psychiatry Psychological Thriller Psychology Psychotherapy Publication Day Reading Rebecca Mascull Reflection Robert Harris Rose Tremain Russian Revolution sacred music Sadie Jones Sci-Fi Science and nature Scottish writer Second World War SF Shakespeare Short stories Simon Mawer Soapbox Spy thriller Susan Hill Tana French The Cold War The Natural World TV Drama Victorian set fiction Whimsy and Fantasy Fiction William Boyd World music review Writing Young Adult Fiction

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • Lady Fancifull
    • Join 771 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Lady Fancifull
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.

    %d bloggers like this: